Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jessica's avatar

Really great content here.

Kevin Mears's avatar

Marci, you asked what would make it more useful, so here is one field. The six you extract describe the obligation: who, what, where in the text, by when, in what words, and what evidence would show it done. None of them describes the obligation's state today. Between "deadline" and "evidence" is where laws actually disappear, and the dashboard has no column for it.

The anecdote at the top shows the shape. An agency learns of a duty when a congressional letter asks where the report is. That letter is a presentation of the claim, and it can get an answer that is not the report: an extension, a notice, a "we are working on it." A tracker with only done and not-done reads that either as green or as nothing.

The states I would add come from a record I keep for reports filed with agencies, sixteen months, five states per entry: delivered, received, responded, referred, disposed. Two rules make it work. A response is not a disposition, so a reply never closes an item. And silence is not an empty cell; it is entered on the date the deadline passed with nothing filed, and it ages. Then the oversight view can show the number Congress actually needs, which is not how many items are overdue but how long each has sat without an answer, and from whom.

If the schema already carries a dated state per obligation with responded held apart from complete, I'm wrong.

1 more comment...

No posts

Ready for more?